In class today I distributed a reading where C.S. Lewis apparently argues that evidentialism is mistaken. Specifically, Lewis seems to think that it's not the case that a Christian's religious beliefs are reasonable just in case they are held in proportion to the Christian's total evidence. Evidentialism seems to say otherwise. So, evidentialism is false.
Critically evaluate the argument(s) found in the reading. Is there any good objection to evidentialism here?
